Is Alfred Stryker the First Joker?

WARNING: THIS POST CONTAINS SPOILERS (from the 1930s through 2016…).  Also, there are lots of pictures.  All images are the property of DC Comics, their parent company, subsidiary, or affiliate, or the creators or artists involved with each image.

Okay, so, who is the Joker?  Who is Alfred Stryker?  Why do I say “The First Joker”?

In Detective Comics #27 The Bat-Man foils the murderous plot of one Alfred Stryker.  It ends with Stryker falling into a vat of chemicals at his factory, Apex Chemicals – he is presumed dead.

Alfred Stryker is the owner of Apex Chemical Corporation.
Detective Comics #27, Alfred Stryker, owner of Apex Chemical Corp.
Batman foils Stryker's plan, Stryker is killed by tumbling into a vat of acid.
Stryker tumbles into the vat of acid.

In Detective Comics #168 the Red Hood jumps into a tank of chemical runoff and is “transformed”, later becoming the Joker (introduced without an origin in Batman #1, one year after Batman’s creation and ten years prior to the Red Hood origin story).  This tank is at a card factory.

Cornered, the Red Hood chooses to jump into a vat of chemicals to escape Batman.
The Red Hood jumps into a tank of chemicals to escape Batman.
The Joker reveals that he swam out of the runoff tank and lived!
Red Hood escapes and becomes The Joker.

In Batman Vol. 2 #13 (New 52, start of the Death of the Family story arc) Batman and Joker go back to “where it all began”, which a panel reveals to be Ace Chemical.

Bottom-right panel.
Bottom-right panel.
A.C.E. Chemical
A.C.E. Chemical

A big part of this issue is that something is different about the Joker, I think this is reintroducing us to the third Joker by referencing the first (and second) Joker’s origin…

Joker is doing his own dirty work.
Joker is doing his own dirty work.
He's not my Mr. J anymore.
He’s not my Mr. J anymore…

We know reality has been messed with a few times, most recently revealed by the Rebirth storyline (and before that was Convergence); Rebirth was immediately preceded by the realization that there are THREE Jokers.  So it is not unreasonable to believe that origin stories have been combined, skewed, or otherwise adjusteded as the story of Batman has progressed.

There are three Jokers?!
There are three Jokers?!
The first Joker is the one on the left.
The first Joker is the one on the left.

For Detective Comics Vol. 2 #27 DC revisited the first batman story – publishing it in it’s original entirety, and doing a special story.  Here is the updated version of Alfred Stryker.

This isn’t the first time we’ve seen a guy in a purple suit with a crow bar
And he's in the vat!!!!
And he’s in the vat!!!!
But he doesn't stay...
But he doesn’t stay…

We even see a glimpse of a future where Bruce has been Batman for 200 years, through the use of clones – and each time he has a Joker to face, each new generation of criminal crowning their own Clown Prince of Crime…

They each learn who the Joker IS, not was
They each learn who the Joker is firsthand.

I like the idea that the first Joker is Alfred Stryker.  Batman’s archenemy, his nemesis, his equal yet opposite, has been there since the very first story…

I know that this isn’t a novel idea, others have had this same thought; but I think new developments make it worth revisiting, and as long as DC doesn’t release his identity (which I actually like) we’re going to keep having fun with it!

As a side note, Joker of The Killing Joke appears to me to be the second Joker.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *